Pine Island Real Estate Search

Pine Island Homes for Sale

Sandwiched between Sanibel Island and Captiva Island and encircled by the Gulf of Mexico on the sunny Southwest coast of Florida, Pine Island is a great place to live. The island encompasses Bokeelia in its north end and Saint James City in its southern end. Located in proximity to the mainland cities of Fort Myers and west of Cape Coral, Pine Island is bordered by Matlacha Island and Matlacha Pass on the east and Pine Island Sound on the west. Pine Island Sound is surrounded by the barrier islands of Cayo Costa, North Captiva, Captiva, and Sanibel, along with Pine Island. These Lee County islands separate the Gulf of Mexico from the sound, and the only highway onto Pine Island is Pine Island Road which cuts through the historic fishing village of Matlacha.

With a delightful Old Florida vibe, the Pine Island community offers quick and easy access to its own amenities and services, as well as those of the neighboring communities. For example, nearby Matlacha, a hip arts community with a Key West vibe, is full of small restaurants, fresh seafood markets, colorful galleries, and quaint shops. There are no high-rise developments in Pine Island, and the beaches are unnamed, but roughly nine thousand people reside here, just thirty minutes from Fort Myers. In addition to its charming small-town ambiance, the island is also known for its fruit groves, tropical plants, acres of palms, beautiful mangroves, three aquatic preserves, and access to some of the world’s best fishing opportunities. 

This family-friendly island is a peaceful place with a wide variety of Pine Island real estate. Homes for sale in Pine Island include townhomes, waterfront cottages, acreages, and modern single-family homes. This means real estate in Pine Island includes properties of many ages, floor plans, architectural designs, sizes, and amenities. Please connect with us today, and we will happily help you with your Pine Island home search by providing details about available properties in Pine Island, Florida.

Our website features the best Pine Island real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Pine Island real estate market? Sign up for a  Pine Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Pine Island Homes and Condos for Sale

$359,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224024283 MLS
REMARKABLE ISLAND HOME...Everything you need in a fully furnished almost turnkey island home. With almost 2400 sqft under one roof - Upstairs you have 2 bedrooms and a den (we use as 3 bedrooms) with walk-in closets, two full baths, kitchen/dining, walk-in pantry and a cozy living room all under a central HVAC system. Downstairs is a large living space that we've used as a [non-conforming] 4th bedroom/family/game room, a separate laundry room under a mini-split HVAC system. A large storage room, plus a large work shop and a single car garage space that a portable a/c is able to manage. You are on Pine Island Water that actually tastes good right from the tap with a fully functional septic system. The primary bedroom is ensuite. The shower is fully tiled with a swinging glass door and plumbed for a steam room. The steam generator is downstairs, below the shower. The metal roof was put on after Hurricane Charlie and is a perfect low (2/12) pitch to deflect hurricane winds. There have never been any water, leaks or stains in the upstairs elevated portion of the home. The front door, kitchen slider and kitchen sink window are all impact rated. The front deck has a sitting area and the large back deck has a shade sail cover making it a nice relaxing island hangout. This is property is zoned TFC2 which means, Lee County could approve a 2nd residence (or rental) to be legally added to the property. The home could be raised or another structure added that is compliant with building, flood and setback codes. This information was confirmed with Lee County Zoning on April 5th, 2024, but buyer should still verify. You have a large U-shaped driveway and tons of parking , so bring your boat, trailer or RV. You also have access to water, septic and a 50 amp electrical hookup for an RV like the 40' motorhome currently hooked up on the side driveway. The community pool, library, park and tennis courts are all within a short walking distance just down the street. Restaurants, gas stations/convenience stores, beauty salon/barber and much more all within walking distance. There is a bike path that runs the length of the island, several nature walking trails and many boat launches on the island for boating and fishing enjoyment. The sellers are the listing agents.

10880 Russell Road, Bokeelia

$269,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 224016870 MLS
Simple Island living! Situated a non-gated & non-deeded neighborhood in Bokeelia, an area of Pine Island known for it's quaint setting & fantastic fishing. Home is to be offered FURNISHED and recent updates include- NEW ROOF (end of 2022), all new appliances, new washer & dryer, new A/C mini split and heat pump system installed in 2022 (wall unit in living room), new gravel driveway, new covered porch out front of home, new hot water heater (2021), and the septic tank last pumped in March 2024. This single family home sits on a deep lot and offers a great room layout, renovated kitchen (w/ designer cabinets, granite countertops & backsplash), breakfast bar & dining area, tile flooring throughout, large laundry room w/ lots of storage space, renovated full bath, 2 guest rooms, huge bonus area that is currently used as a workshop, screened lanai, 12x16 detached shed w/ carport, and a large backyard that has plenty of room for a pool/playset/trampoline OR can be used to store RV/boat. A new hot water heater has just been installed and one of the a/c units was replaced this year as well. There is a gorgeous banyan tree covering the front of the home surrounded by natural Old Florida landscaping and providing shade for the home. Pine Island & Matlacha feature fishing charters, day excursions to surrounding islands, art galleries, boutiques, community parks & preserve areas, fabulous seafood restaurants, and a peaceful waterfront/island atmosphere.

5507 Thomas Street, Bokeelia

Start Your Search